Hi Jacqueline, thank you for your feedback. We're so glad to hear you enjoyed the product! We’re sorry to hear there was confusion around the Buy One, Get One (BOGO) offer, and we’d love the chance to clarify. To receive the BOGO deal, customers need to select the “Subscribe & Save” option on the promotional product page. This applies the first-time subscriber discount, which includes 50–75% off (depending on the product) and a free second box on the first order. After that, ongoing shipments are billed at our renewal up to 15% off subscriber discount. We understand $85 can feel like a lot, which is why our subscription pricing is designed to let customers try the product at a significantly reduced rate — and you can cancel or manage your subscription at any time, no commitment required. We appreciate your honesty and the opportunity to improve the experience.